Triathlon Homes LLP v Stratford Village Development Partnership & Anor

Issue

Design and construction defects in cladding systems on five residential blocks at the former London 2012 Olympic athletes’ village, Stratford (now East Village). Fire safety defects discovered November 2020; total remediation cost ~£24.5m. Triathlon sought a Remediation Contribution Order (RCO) under s.124 Building Safety Act 2022 for ~£18m against SVDP (developer) and Get Living plc (its parent company, now owner).

  1. The Grenfell Tower fire in June 2017 precipitated a review by EVML of the cladding materials utilised at East Village. The initial investigation took the form of desk top studies and concentrated on identifying the presence of the ACM cladding which had been implicated as a primary cause of the rapid spread of the fire at Grenfell. The buildings at East Village were, for the most part, clad in masonry, including brick and pre-cast concrete, but ACM material was soon found to have been used in limited locations on eight buildings in Plots N02 and N07 but not in Plot N26. The design and implementation of a remedial scheme to remove this ACM cladding was EVML’s first priority and removal was completed by January 2021, but it soon appreciated that there were more widespread problems. The earliest issue to be suspected at Plot N26 related to compartmentation which was reported to the board as being under investigation in May 2018.

Outcome

  • FTT: first contested RCO under s.124 BSA 2022. Held it just and equitable to order SVDP, and its wealthy parent Get Living, to pay — the BSA is intended to prevent well-capitalised parents hiding behind under-funded SPVs. Get Living was “associated” with SVDP via the freeholder/landlord chain of title.
  • Court of Appeal: dismissed SVDP’s appeal. Confirmed (a) it was just and equitable to make the RCO, and (b) an RCO can be made in respect of costs incurred before s.124 came into force (28 June 2022) — i.e. retrospective effect. Drew on URS Corporation v BDW Trading as to the BSA’s policy.

Notes

  • Heard together with Adriatic Land 5 v Hippersley Point.
  • Confirms the “association” test under s.130 BSA captures both direct and indirect control, and that later corporate changes (e.g. acquisition after practical completion) do not shield a parent from liability.